How to Do an SEO + AI Competitor Analysis and Beat the Competition (2025 Guide)

You've poured hours into creating content, optimizing pages, and building links—yet your competitors still outrank you. Sound familiar?

Here's the reality: 92% of global traffic comes from Google, and 75% of users never scroll past the first page. If your competitors claim those top spots, they're capturing the traffic, leads, and customers that could be yours.

An SEO competitor analysis is the process of evaluating your competitors' SEO strategies—including their keywords, content, backlinks, and technical performance—to identify opportunities to outrank them. By reverse-engineering what works for your rivals, you can replicate their successes and exploit their weaknesses without years of trial and error.

In this guide, you'll learn a proven 4-step framework for SEO competitive analysis that works with any tool—whether you're using Frase, Semrush, Ahrefs, or free alternatives. You'll discover how to:

• Identify your true SEO competitors (they're not who you think they are)
• Find quick-win keywords your competitors are missing
• Analyze content that's actually driving rankings and traffic
• Build a backlink strategy based on proven results
• Turn insights into action with a clear prioritization framework

The best part? You don't need expensive tools or years of experience. This framework gives you actionable tactics, not just theory. Used by over 30,000 content teams worldwide, these strategies help businesses of all sizes outrank their competition.

Let's dive in.

What is an SEO Competitor Analysis?

An SEO competitor analysis is a systematic evaluation of competing websites' search engine optimization strategies and performance. Unlike a general competitive analysis that examines products, pricing, or market positioning, SEO competitive analysis focuses specifically on how rivals achieve visibility in search engines.

The process involves examining four critical areas:

1. Keywords — Which search terms drive traffic to competitor sites
2. Content — What content formats and topics earn rankings and engagement
3. Backlinks — Where competitors get their authority and link equity from
4. Technical SEO — How site structure, speed, and optimization impact performance

Why SEO Competitor Analysis Matters

Understanding your competitors' SEO strategies delivers measurable business impact. Here's why it matters:

Organic search accounts for 53% of website traffic, making it the second-highest traffic channel after direct visits. When competitors rank above you, they're not just getting more visibility—they're capturing potential customers who are actively searching for solutions you provide.

Consider the advantage: top-ranking pages have 3.8x more backlinks than positions 2-10. By analyzing how top performers built their authority, you can replicate proven strategies rather than guessing what might work.

Competitor analysis also reveals content gaps. Only 2.2% of content published online generates more than one unique backlink, which means most content fails to attract links. By studying the 2.2% that succeeds, you learn what makes content link-worthy.

Business vs. SEO Competitors: A Critical Distinction

Your business competitors aren't necessarily your SEO competitors—and understanding this distinction is crucial for effective analysis.

Business competitors sell similar products or services to the same target audience. They're the companies you compete with for customers, contracts, and market share.

SEO competitors rank for your target keywords in search results. These could be:

• Direct business competitors who also invest in SEO
• Industry publications like TechCrunch or Forbes
• Authority sites like Wikipedia or government resources
• Niche blogs focused on specific topics you target
• Q&A sites like Reddit or Quora

For example, a local bakery's business competitors are other bakeries in their city. But their SEO competitors for "how to make sourdough bread" might include King Arthur Baking, The Kitchn, and individual food bloggers—none of whom sell baked goods.

This distinction matters because your SEO strategy should focus on outranking whoever appears in search results for your target keywords, regardless of whether they're business rivals.

When to Conduct SEO Competitor Analysis

Strategic timing maximizes the impact of competitive analysis:

Before launching a content strategy — Research competitors to inform topic selection, content depth, and differentiation angles

When competitors outrank you — Identify specific factors (keywords, content quality, backlinks, technical issues) causing the ranking gap

Quarterly strategy reviews — Monitor competitive landscape shifts, algorithm update impacts, and emerging competitors

After major algorithm updates — Understand how changes affected your rankings relative to competitors and adjust accordingly

When entering new markets — Study established players to accelerate your entry and avoid costly mistakes

Regular competitive analysis, combined with trigger-based reviews, ensures your SEO strategy remains responsive to market dynamics.

The 4-Step SEO Competitor Analysis Framework

Success in SEO isn't about having the most expensive tools—it's about having a systematic approach to extract insights and take action.

This 4-step framework works whether you're using premium platforms like Frase, Semrush, and Ahrefs, or starting with free alternatives. The principles remain the same: identify, analyze, prioritize, execute.

Framework Overview

Step 1: Identify Your True SEO Competitors

Find out who's actually competing for your target keywords in search results (spoiler: it's often not your business competitors).

Step 2: Analyze Competitor Keywords

Discover which keywords drive traffic to competitor sites, identify gaps in your own keyword targeting, and find question-based opportunities that reveal user intent.

Step 3: Evaluate Competitor Content & Backlinks

Assess what makes competitor content rank and attract links, then identify opportunities to create something better.

Step 4: Turn Insights Into Action

Use a prioritization framework to focus on high-impact opportunities and create an actionable roadmap for outranking competitors.

Each step builds on the previous one, creating a comprehensive competitive intelligence foundation for your SEO strategy. The framework is scalable—use it to analyze a single competitor or evaluate an entire competitive landscape.

Let's break down each step.

Step 1: How to Identify Your True SEO Competitors

Before you can outrank competitors, you need to know who they are. This step reveals your real competition in search results.

Why This Step Matters

Many businesses waste time analyzing the wrong competitors. They focus on direct business rivals who barely invest in SEO, while missing the authority sites, publications, and niche blogs that actually dominate their target keywords.

Your SEO competitors are determined by one factor: who ranks for the keywords you want to rank for. That's it.

Method 1: Manual SERP Analysis (Free)

The simplest approach requires no tools—just Google and a spreadsheet.

Process:

1. List your 10-15 most important target keywords
2. Search each keyword in Google (use incognito mode to avoid personalized results)
3. Note the domains consistently appearing in positions 1-10
4. Create a tracking spreadsheet with columns for: Domain, Average Position, Frequency (how often they appear)
5. Identify patterns—domains appearing for multiple keywords are your primary competitors

Pro tip: Focus on domains, not individual pages. If you see blog.competitor.com and shop.competitor.com, treat them as the same competitor (competitor.com).

After reviewing 10-15 keywords, you'll typically see 5-10 domains appearing repeatedly. These are your true SEO competitors.

Method 2: Using SEO Tools

SEO tools accelerate competitor identification by analyzing thousands of keywords simultaneously.

With Frase:

1. Enter your target keyword in Frase's SERP analyzer
2. Review the top-ranking domains for that query
3. Use Frase's question research tool to find competitors ranking for related question queries
4. Export the competitive domain list

With Semrush:

1. Navigate to Organic Research tool
2. Enter your domain
3. Click the "Competitors" tab
4. Review domains by "Common Keywords" and "Competition Level"
5. Filter by competitors with significant keyword overlap

With Ahrefs:

1. Open Site Explorer
2. Enter your domain
3. Navigate to "Competing Domains"
4. Sort by "Common Keywords" or "Traffic Value"
5. Identify top 5-10 competitors

Free Alternative:

Use Google Search Console to see queries where you rank in positions 4-20, then manually search those queries to identify who ranks above you.

How Many Competitors to Track

Quality beats quantity. Start with 3-5 primary competitors representing different competitive categories:

Category 1: Direct Business Competitor

A company selling similar products/services with strong SEO presence

Category 2: Authority Publication

Industry-leading publication or media site (e.g., Forbes, TechCrunch for tech topics)

Category 3: Niche Content Site

Specialized blog or resource focused on your specific niche

Category 4: Question-Based Competitor

Sites ranking for question queries related to your topics (valuable for answer engine optimization)

Category 5: Emerging Competitor

Newer site growing quickly in your space (watch for tactics that work)

This mix provides diverse insights—established tactics from authorities, niche strategies from specialists, and innovative approaches from emerging players.

Quick Win: Find Question-Based Competitors

Question keywords reveal user intent and create opportunities for featured snippets and AI search citations.

Use Frase's question research tool to discover which competitors consistently answer questions in your niche. These sites often use FAQ schemas, direct-answer formatting, and comprehensive guides—all tactics you can adapt and improve upon.

Actionable Checklist

☐ List 10-15 target keywords

☐ Search each in Google and document top 10 results

☐ Identify 3-5 domains appearing most frequently

☐ Categorize competitors (business, authority, niche, etc.)

☐ Create competitor tracking spreadsheet

☐ Note each competitor's apparent content strategy

Output: A prioritized list of 3-5 SEO competitors to analyze in depth.

Step 2: Competitor Keyword Analysis

Keywords reveal where your competitors get their traffic and where opportunities exist for you to capture market share.

54% of businesses generate links through competitor analysis and link targeting, proving that understanding competitor keywords drives real results.

Finding Competitor Keywords

Every SEO tool offers keyword analysis, but the approach varies. Here's how to extract maximum value from each platform.

With Frase:

Frase excels at question-based keyword research, revealing opportunities traditional tools miss:

1. Enter a competitor URL into Frase's SERP analyzer
2. Review ranking keywords with search volume and difficulty metrics
3. Use the question research tool to find question variations and "People Also Ask" queries
4. Export keyword opportunities focusing on questions you can answer better

With Semrush:

1. Navigate to Keyword Gap tool
2. Enter your domain and up to 4 competitor domains
3. Click "Compare"
4. Filter by "Missing" keywords (they rank, you don't)
5. Sort by search volume and keyword difficulty
6. Export promising keywords to Keyword Strategy Builder

With Ahrefs:

1. Open Site Explorer and enter competitor domain
2. Navigate to "Organic keywords" report
3. Sort by "Traffic" to see highest-value keywords
4. Use "Content Gap" tool to compare multiple competitors
5. Filter by keyword difficulty under 40 for quick wins

Free Alternative:

Use Google Keyword Planner combined with manual SERP research. Enter competitor URLs, extract keyword ideas, then manually validate search volume and difficulty by reviewing SERP competition.

What to Look For

Not all competitor keywords deserve your attention. Focus on these categories:

High-Value Keywords

• Significant search volume (varies by niche, but typically 500+ monthly searches)
• Commercial or transactional intent (users ready to buy or take action)
• Relevance to your core offerings

Quick-Win Keywords

• Low to medium keyword difficulty (KD under 40)
• Your domain has topical authority to compete
• Competitors have thin or outdated content

Question-Based Keywords

• Start with who, what, when, where, why, how
• Trigger "People Also Ask" boxes
• Opportunity for featured snippets

SERP Feature Keywords

• Display featured snippets
• Show "People Also Ask" expansions
• Include video carousels or image packs
• Present local pack results

Conducting a Keyword Gap Analysis

A keyword gap analysis reveals the specific keywords where competitors outperform you—and more importantly, why.

The Process:

1. Export competitor ranking keywords from your chosen tool
2. Cross-reference with your own keyword rankings
3. Categorize keywords into three buckets:

• Missing keywords — Competitors rank, you have no content
• Underperforming keywords — Both rank, they outrank you
• Quick wins — Low difficulty, high relevance, you can rank quickly

1. Filter by search volume (focus on keywords with meaningful traffic potential)
2. Assess keyword difficulty against your domain authority
3. Prioritize based on business value and ranking feasibility

The 3 Types of Keyword Gaps:

Missing Keywords represent pure opportunity. Competitors attract traffic for these queries, but you don't even compete. These often reveal content topics you haven't covered or product/service pages you should create.

Underperforming Keywords show where improvement matters most. You've invested in content for these keywords but competitors outrank you. Analyze why: Is their content more comprehensive? Do they have better backlinks? Is their technical SEO superior?

Quick Wins are your starting point. These low-difficulty keywords let you gain traction fast, build authority, and generate momentum. Target these first while planning longer-term campaigns for competitive keywords.

Question Research for Competitive Advantage

Questions reveal user intent better than keywords alone, and they're essential for answer engine optimization (AEO)—optimizing for AI search tools like ChatGPT and Perplexity.

Traditional SEO tools show you that competitors rank for "email marketing"—but Frase's question research reveals they're answering specific questions like:

• How do I build an email list from scratch?
• What's the best email marketing tool for small business?
• How often should I send marketing emails?

Each question represents a specific user need you can address with targeted content.

Using Frase for Question Research:

1. Enter your main topic or competitor URL in Frase
2. Review the "Questions" tab to see what people are asking
3. Identify questions your competitors haven't answered comprehensively
4. Find question clusters (related questions that could form a pillar content piece)
5. Create content specifically structured to answer these questions

Why This Matters:

Voice search adoption continues growing, and question-based queries dominate voice interactions. Featured snippets typically answer questions. AI search engines like ChatGPT cite sources that provide direct, clear answers to questions.

By focusing on question research, you optimize for multiple ranking opportunities simultaneously—traditional search, voice search, featured snippets, and AI citations.

Actionable Output

Create a keyword targeting spreadsheet with these columns:

• Keyword/Question
• Search Volume
• Keyword Difficulty
• Current Ranking (yours)
• Top Competitor (who ranks #1)
• Content Gap (what's missing in existing content)
• Priority Score (calculated based on opportunity)
• Target Publish Date

This spreadsheet becomes your content calendar foundation—prioritize highest-value keywords and create content to fill each gap.

Step 3: Competitor Content Analysis

Keywords tell you what to create. Content analysis tells you how to create it better than anyone else.

Content over 3,000 words wins 3x more traffic than average-length content, but length alone doesn't guarantee success. Quality, structure, and optimization matter more.

Analyzing Top-Performing Competitor Content

Start by identifying which competitor pages drive the most traffic and rankings, then dissect what makes them successful.

Content Audit Process:

1. Use your SEO tool to identify competitor's top pages by estimated traffic
2. Analyze the top 5-10 performing pages
3. Look for patterns in content type, format, depth, and structure
4. Note engagement signals (social shares, backlinks, comments)
5. Identify common elements across high-performers

Metrics to Track:

• Estimated organic traffic
• Number of ranking keywords
• Total backlinks
• Referring domains
• Social shares (when available)
• Published/updated dates

Pages ranking for hundreds of keywords and driving thousands of monthly visitors reveal what resonates with both users and search engines.

The Content Quality Scorecard

Use this framework to objectively evaluate competitor content and identify improvement opportunities.

1. Depth & Comprehensiveness (Score 1-10)

• Word count: How does length compare to your content?
• Topic coverage: Do they address all aspects of the topic?
• Supporting elements: Examples, case studies, data, expert quotes?
• Unique insights: Original research or perspectives?

A score of 8+ indicates comprehensive coverage that will be difficult to beat without significant effort.

2. Formatting & Readability (Score 1-10)

• Structure: Clear H2/H3 hierarchy?
• Visual elements: Images, videos, infographics, charts?
• Scannability: Short paragraphs, bullet points, bolded key points?
• White space: Easy to read without feeling overwhelming?

High scores here indicate attention to user experience, not just SEO.

3. SEO Optimization (Score 1-10)

• Keyword placement: Target keyword in title, headers, intro, conclusion?
• Internal linking: Links to related content on their site?
• External linking: Cites authoritative sources?
• Schema markup: Structured data implementation?
• Meta optimization: Optimized title tags and meta descriptions?

This reveals how technically sophisticated their SEO approach is.

4. User Experience (Score 1-10)

• Page speed: Loads in under 3 seconds?
• Mobile optimization: Responsive design and mobile-friendly?
• Navigation: Easy to find related content?
• CTAs: Clear calls to action without being pushy?
• Design quality: Professional, modern appearance?

User experience impacts both rankings (Core Web Vitals) and conversion rates.

Reverse-Engineering Competitor Content Briefs

Top-performing content follows a strategic brief. By reverse-engineering competitor content, you can extract that brief and improve upon it.

What to Extract:

Outline structure: Note every H2 and H3 heading. This reveals their content flow and topic coverage.

Word count targets: Count total words and words per section. This shows how deeply they cover each topic.

Questions answered: List every question they explicitly answer. Look for FAQ sections and in-content questions.

Sources cited: Note which sources they reference. Check if sources are current and authoritative.

Visual assets: Document every image, chart, video, or infographic. Visual content often correlates with higher engagement.

How to Create Something Better:

1. Add unique data — Original research, surveys, or proprietary statistics
2. Answer more questions — Use Frase to find related questions they missed
3. Update information — Refresh outdated statistics and examples
4. Improve formatting — Make content more scannable with better visual hierarchy
5. Include expert perspectives — Interviews or quotes from industry authorities
6. Create superior visuals — Custom graphics, not just stock photos

The goal isn't to copy—it's to understand what works, then make something demonstrably better. Learn how to create comprehensive content briefs that guide superior content creation.

SERP Feature Analysis

SERP features offer additional visibility beyond traditional rankings. Analyzing which competitors own these features reveals optimization opportunities.

Featured Snippets:

Featured snippets appear above position 1, making them "position zero." They answer user questions directly in search results.

Analysis checklist:

• Which competitors own featured snippets for your target keywords?
• What format do they use? (paragraph, list, table, video)
• How do they structure the answer? (word count, specificity)
• What schema markup supports the snippet?

Optimization approach: Create content specifically formatted to answer the question concisely in 40-60 words, followed by comprehensive details.

People Also Ask (PAA):

PAA boxes show related questions users commonly search for. Appearing here drives qualified traffic and reveals content expansion opportunities.

Analysis checklist:

• What questions appear in PAA for your keywords?
• Which competitors appear in these expanded questions?
• What content structure do they use to capture PAA placement?

Optimization approach: Create comprehensive FAQ content addressing all related PAA questions with clear, direct answers.

Other SERP Features to Analyze:

• Local packs — For local search terms
• Knowledge panels — For branded searches
• Video results — YouTube or video content
• Image packs — Visual content opportunities
• Top stories — News and recent content

Each SERP feature represents a different way to capture visibility and traffic beyond traditional organic rankings.

Actionable Checklist

☐ Identify top 5 competitor pages per target keyword

☐ Score content quality using the 4-category framework

☐ Document content structure (H2/H3 outline)

☐ Note SERP features competitors own

☐ List improvement opportunities for each target keyword

☐ Create "beat this content" plan with specific differentiators

Output: A clear roadmap of what to create and how to make it better than existing top-ranking content.

Step 4: Competitor Backlink Analysis

Backlinks remain one of the top three ranking factors. Top-ranking pages have 3.8x more backlinks than positions 2-10, making backlink analysis crucial for competitive SEO.

Understanding Backlink Metrics

Before analyzing competitor backlinks, understand the key metrics that indicate link profile strength and quality.

Total Backlinks

The raw number of links pointing to a site. While quantity matters, quality matters more—a thousand low-quality links won't outperform ten authoritative ones.

Referring Domains

The number of unique websites linking to a site. More important than total backlinks because 100 links from one domain provide less value than links from 100 different domains.

Domain Authority (DA) / Domain Rating (DR)

Proprietary metrics from Moz (DA) and Ahrefs (DR) that estimate a domain's ranking potential based on backlink profile quality. Scores range from 1-100, with higher indicating stronger domains.

Link Velocity

How quickly a site gains or loses backlinks over time. Natural growth is gradual and consistent; sudden spikes may indicate unnatural link building.

Anchor Text Distribution

The text used in hyperlinks pointing to a site. Natural profiles include branded anchors, generic terms, and a small percentage of exact-match keywords. Over-optimized anchor text (too many exact matches) can trigger penalties.

Analyzing Competitor Backlink Profiles

Use these tools and techniques to dissect where competitors get their authority:

With Ahrefs (Best for Backlink Data):

Ahrefs maintains the industry's largest backlink database with 43 trillion links.

1. Enter competitor domain in Site Explorer
2. Review "Overview" metrics (DR, referring domains, backlinks)
3. Click "Backlinks" to see all links
4. Filter by "Dofollow" and sort by "DR" to find highest-value links
5. Analyze "Anchors" report to see anchor text distribution
6. Check "Referring domains" for domain-level insights

With Semrush:

1. Navigate to Backlink Analytics
2. Enter competitor domain
3. Review authority score and referring domains
4. Analyze "Backlinks" tab with filters for link type
5. Check "Anchors" to assess anchor text strategy
6. Review "Indexed pages" to see which pages attract most links

With Frase:

Frase integrates backlink insights within competitive analysis, showing which competitor pages have the strongest link profiles relative to target keywords.

Free Alternative:

Google Search Console shows your own backlink profile. For competitors, use limited free reports from Ahrefs or Moz, combined with manual research.

Finding Link Building Opportunities

The real value of backlink analysis isn't understanding competitors—it's finding opportunities to build your own high-quality links.

Strategy 1: Competitor Backlink Replication

Identify high-authority sites linking to competitors, then target those same sites for your own link building.

Process:

1. Find high-DR sites (50+) linking to competitors
2. Analyze why they linked (specific content, resource page, guest post, partnership)
3. Identify content on your site that could earn similar links
4. If you lack suitable content, create something better
5. Reach out to site owners with a value-driven pitch

Example: If three competitors have links from an industry association's resource page, contact that association to request inclusion with your superior resource.

Strategy 2: Broken Link Building

66% of backlinks are broken, creating massive opportunity.

Process:

1. Find broken backlinks pointing to competitor sites (404 errors)
2. Analyze what content the broken link originally pointed to
3. Create content covering that topic (or identify existing content on your site)
4. Contact sites with broken links and suggest your content as a replacement

This works because you're helping webmasters fix problems on their sites while earning a valuable link.

Strategy 3: Link Intersect Method

Find sites linking to multiple competitors but not to you—they're proven linkers in your niche.

Process:

1. Enter 2-3 competitor domains in Ahrefs' Link Intersect tool
2. Add your domain to exclude sites already linking to you
3. Review domains linking to multiple competitors
4. Analyze why they link (content type, relationship, etc.)
5. Create outreach list prioritized by relevance and authority

Sites linking to multiple competitors demonstrate they actively link out in your niche, making them high-probability targets.

Assessing Link Quality

Not all backlinks provide equal value. Focus on quality indicators to build a strong, sustainable link profile.

High-Quality Link Indicators:

• Domain authority 40+ — Links from authoritative sites pass more value
• Topical relevance — Links from sites in your niche or related topics
• Editorial placement — Links within content, not footers or sidebars
• Dofollow attribute — Passes link equity (though some nofollow links have value)
• Traffic to linking page — Links from pages with traffic are more valuable
• Contextual anchor text — Natural-sounding anchor text within relevant content

Low-Quality/Toxic Link Warnings:

• Spammy anchor text — Over-optimized, keyword-stuffed anchors
• Unrelated websites — Links from sites completely outside your industry
• Link farms — Sites that exist only to sell links
• Foreign language sites — Unless you're targeting that market
• Sitewide links — Links from every page of a site (often footer links)
• Low DR/DA — Links from very new or weak domains

Here's an uncomfortable truth: 91.89% of SEOs believe their competitors buy backlinks. While paid links violate Google's guidelines, they're common in competitive industries.

Your approach should focus on earning links through quality content rather than buying them. Black-hat tactics offer short-term gains but risk long-term penalties.

Actionable Output

Create a link building target list with these columns:

• Target Domain
• Domain Authority
• Why They Link (content type, relationship, etc.)
• Outreach Angle (your pitch approach)
• Priority (High/Medium/Low based on authority + feasibility)
• Contact Information
• Outreach Date
• Status (Not Contacted / Pending / Success / No Response)

This becomes your link building roadmap—work through targets systematically based on priority.

How to Prioritize & Take Action

Analysis without action is just research. This step transforms insights into ranking improvements.

The Opportunity Scoring Framework

Not all competitive insights deserve equal attention. Use this framework to focus on high-impact opportunities.

Score Each Opportunity (1-10 scale):

Impact Potential

• How much traffic could this opportunity generate?
• What's the conversion potential of this traffic?
• How likely is it to improve rankings significantly?

Competitive Advantage

• How much better can your content be vs. competitors?
• How strong is the current competition for this keyword/topic?
• Is the market saturated or is there room to differentiate?

Effort Required

• How much time will this take to execute?
• What resources (team, budget, tools) do you need?
• What's the technical complexity?

Calculate Priority Score:

Priority Score = (Impact × Competitive Advantage) / Effort

Focus first on opportunities with the highest scores—these deliver the best return on your investment.

Example Calculation:

Opportunity: Target "email marketing automation" keyword

• Impact: 8/10 (high search volume, commercial intent)
• Competitive Advantage: 6/10 (can create better content than current #1)
• Effort: 7/10 (requires comprehensive 4,000-word guide + graphics)

Priority Score = (8 × 6) / 7 = 6.86

Compare this score against other opportunities to determine what to tackle first.

Quick Wins vs. Long-Term Investments

Balance your SEO strategy between immediate gains and sustainable growth.

Quick Wins (Execute First):

Low-difficulty keywords — Target keywords with KD under 30 where you can rank within weeks

Broken link opportunities — Reach out to sites with broken backlinks to competitors (results in days)

Missing schema markup — Add structured data to existing pages (implement in hours)

Internal linking improvements — Connect related content on your site (execute in days)

Content refreshes — Update top-performing content with new data and improved formatting (complete in days)

Quick wins build momentum, demonstrate ROI to stakeholders, and generate traffic while longer-term strategies develop.

Long-Term Investments (Plan Now, Execute Over Months):

High-difficulty keywords — Competitive terms requiring authority building before you can rank

Comprehensive pillar content — In-depth guides of 4,000+ words requiring significant research and production

Strategic backlink acquisition — Building relationships and earning links from high-authority sites

Technical site overhauls — Major improvements to site structure, speed, and crawlability

These investments pay dividends over time but require patience and consistent effort.

Creating Your Action Plan

Transform your competitor analysis into a structured execution roadmap.

Content Strategy:

1. Content to create — Keyword-mapped list of new content targeting gaps
2. Content to update — Existing pages to refresh with better optimization
3. Content to consolidate — Similar pages to merge for stronger authority
4. Content to delete — Thin, duplicate, or outdated content hurting your site

Link Building Strategy:

1. High-priority link targets — Domains to contact with prepared outreach templates
2. Content assets for links — Guides, research, or tools to attract links naturally
3. Broken link opportunities — Sites to contact about broken backlinks
4. Toxic link removal — Low-quality links to disavow or request removal

Technical Improvements:

1. Page speed optimizations — Compress images, minify code, enable caching
2. Schema markup additions — Implement Article, FAQ, BreadcrumbList schemas
3. Mobile UX improvements — Enhance mobile responsiveness and usability
4. Internal linking adjustments — Apply 40/40/20 distribution (40% blog, 40% features, 20% conversion pages)

Execution Timeline:

30-Day Quick Wins:

• Add schema markup to top 10 pages
• Optimize existing content for 5 quick-win keywords
• Fix top 10 technical SEO issues
• Launch outreach for 10 broken link opportunities

90-Day Strategic Initiatives:

• Create 5 comprehensive guides targeting competitive keywords
• Execute link building campaign targeting 30 high-authority domains
• Implement site-wide technical improvements
• Refresh top 20% of existing content

Ongoing Optimization:

• Monthly: Review rankings, traffic, and backlink growth
• Quarterly: Conduct fresh competitor analysis to identify new opportunities
• Continuously: Publish new content and build relationships for links

This structured approach ensures consistent progress without becoming overwhelming.

Common SEO Competitor Analysis Mistakes to Avoid

Learn from these common pitfalls to maximize the impact of your competitive analysis.

Mistake #1: Analyzing the Wrong Competitors

Many businesses waste time analyzing direct business competitors who barely invest in SEO, while missing the content sites and authority publishers dominating their target keywords.

Solution: Always let SERP results determine your SEO competitors. Search your target keywords, note who ranks consistently, and analyze those sites regardless of whether they're business rivals.

Mistake #2: Analysis Paralysis

Spending months gathering data without taking action yields zero results. Perfect analysis doesn't exist—you need 80% of insights to start making improvements.

Solution: Follow the 4-step framework, spend 1-2 days on analysis, then move to execution. You can always refine your approach as you learn what works.

Mistake #3: Copying Instead of Creating Something Better

Replicating competitor content rarely beats the original. Search engines and users reward superior quality, unique perspectives, and fresh insights.

Solution: Use competitor analysis to understand what works, then create something 10x better—more comprehensive, better formatted, more current, with unique data or expert insights competitors lack.

Mistake #4: Ignoring Technical SEO

Great content with poor technical SEO won't rank. Page speed, mobile optimization, structured data, and crawlability all impact performance.

Solution: Include technical audit in your competitive analysis. Use free tools like Google PageSpeed Insights and Mobile-Friendly Test to benchmark your technical performance against competitors.

Mistake #5: One-Time Analysis

SEO is dynamic. Competitors launch new content, build new links, and adjust strategies. Algorithm updates shift the landscape. One-time analysis becomes outdated quickly.

Solution: Schedule quarterly competitive reviews to stay current. Set up monitoring alerts for competitor ranking changes, new content, and backlink acquisitions.

Mistake #6: Not Measuring Results

You can't improve what you don't measure. Without baseline metrics and progress tracking, you won't know if your strategy is working.

Solution: Document current rankings, traffic, and backlinks before implementing changes. Track these metrics monthly to quantify improvement and adjust tactics based on results.

Mistake #7: Focusing Only on Weaknesses

Identifying what competitors do better is important, but don't ignore your own strengths. Doubling down on what you already do well can be more effective than trying to match competitors in every area.

Solution: Balance defensive (fix weaknesses) and offensive (leverage strengths) strategies. Build on your unique advantages while addressing critical gaps.

Mistake #8: Overlooking Small Competitors

Large competitors get attention, but small, agile competitors often innovate tactics that bigger players adopt later. Niche sites can reveal efficient strategies for specific topics.

Solution: Include diverse competitor sizes in your analysis—established authorities, mid-size content sites, and emerging players. Each offers different insights.

How Often Should You Conduct Competitor Analysis?

Strategic timing and frequency maximize the ROI of competitive analysis efforts.

Recommended Frequency

Monthly Quick Checks (2-3 hours)

Monitor high-level changes without deep analysis:

• Ranking shifts for your top 20 keywords
• New content published by top competitors
• Significant backlink gains or losses
• SERP feature changes (snippet theft, new PAA questions)

Use rank tracking tools to automate most monitoring—review dashboards monthly rather than manually checking every keyword.

Quarterly Detailed Analysis (1 full day)

Conduct systematic competitive analysis:

• Full keyword gap analysis for new opportunities
• Comprehensive backlink profile review
• Content strategy assessment (what's working for competitors)
• Technical SEO performance benchmarking

This frequency keeps you current without becoming overwhelmed by constant analysis.

Annual Deep Dive (2-3 days)

Step back for strategic assessment:

• Evaluate overall competitive landscape shifts
• Identify emerging competitors and new threats
• Review market positioning and differentiation opportunities
• Assess whether current SEO strategy aligns with competitive reality

Annual deep dives inform major strategic decisions and budget planning.

Trigger-Based Analysis

Beyond scheduled reviews, conduct competitive analysis when specific events occur:

After major algorithm updates — Understand how changes affected rankings across your competitive set

When launching new products/services — Research competitors already serving that market

After significant ranking drops — Identify what competitors improved while you declined

When new competitors enter your market — Assess their strategy and differentiation approach

Before major content campaigns — Validate topic selection and differentiation angles

When considering expansion — Research competitive landscape in new geographic or topical areas

Time Investment Guidelines

Small Business/Solo Practitioner:

• Monthly monitoring: 1-2 hours
• Quarterly analysis: 4-6 hours
• Annual review: 8-12 hours

Mid-Size Business/Marketing Team:

• Monthly monitoring: 2-3 hours
• Quarterly analysis: 8-16 hours (1-2 days)
• Annual review: 16-24 hours (2-3 days)

Enterprise/Agency:

• Monthly monitoring: 4-8 hours (automated dashboards reduce manual work)
• Quarterly analysis: 16-32 hours (2-4 days across team)
• Annual review: 40+ hours (comprehensive competitive intelligence)

Automation to Reduce Manual Work

Set up automated monitoring to reduce time spent on routine checks:

Rank tracking alerts — Receive notifications when competitors enter top 10 for your target keywords

Backlink monitoring — Get alerts when competitors gain high-authority backlinks

Content publication tracking — RSS feeds or tools like Feedly to monitor competitor blog posts

SERP feature changes — Track when competitors win or lose featured snippets

Automation lets you focus analysis time on strategic insights rather than data collection.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does an SEO competitor analysis take?

A basic competitor analysis takes 4-6 hours if you're using SEO tools and following a systematic framework. A comprehensive deep-dive analysis can require 2-3 full days, especially when analyzing multiple competitors across keywords, content, backlinks, and technical factors.

Using tools like Frase, Semrush, or Ahrefs significantly accelerates data collection, letting you spend more time on strategic analysis and action planning rather than manual research.

What if I'm in a very competitive niche?

Focus on long-tail keywords and question-based queries where competition is lower. Use Frase's question research to find specific questions your competitors haven't thoroughly answered. Consider targeting adjacent topics or more specific sub-niches where you can build authority before competing for broader, more competitive terms.

Additionally, analyze smaller competitors who successfully compete against established players—they often reveal efficient tactics that work despite limited resources.

How many competitors should I analyze?

Start with 3-5 main competitors representing different competitive categories: direct business competitors with strong SEO, authority publications in your industry, niche content sites, and emerging players. Quality beats quantity—it's better to deeply analyze 3 competitors than superficially review 20.

As you become more experienced with competitive analysis, you can expand to 7-10 competitors for more comprehensive market intelligence.

Can I do competitor analysis without paid tools?

Yes. Use Google Search Console for your own performance data, Google Keyword Planner for basic keyword research, manual SERP analysis to identify competitors, and free versions of tools like Ubersuggest, Moz, or Ahrefs (with limited queries). The process takes longer without paid tools, but the framework and insights remain valuable.

Consider investing in paid platforms like Frase to accelerate the ROI on your SEO efforts.

What's the difference between SEO competitors and business competitors?

Business competitors sell similar products or services to the same target customers—you compete with them for sales, market share, and customer loyalty. SEO competitors rank for your target keywords in search results—you compete with them for visibility, traffic, and search engine real estate.

These categories often overlap, but not always. A blog, publication, or Wikipedia might be your SEO competitor without being a business rival. Focus SEO analysis on whoever ranks for keywords you're targeting.

Should I analyze competitors in other languages or countries?

Only if you're actively targeting those markets. For multilingual or international SEO, analyze competitors separately for each target language and region, as ranking factors, search behavior, and competitive landscapes vary significantly by market.

If you're targeting French-speaking users, analyze French-language competitors. If you're US-focused, analyzing UK or Australian competitors provides less actionable insights.

How do I know if my competitor is buying backlinks?

Look for sudden spikes in backlink acquisition, links from completely unrelated or low-quality sites, over-optimized exact-match anchor text patterns, or sitewide links from multiple domains with similar characteristics.

However, focus your energy on your own white-hat link building through quality content, relationship building, and digital PR rather than trying to replicate potentially risky tactics competitors use.

What if my competitors are much bigger brands with larger budgets?

Target long-tail keywords and niche topics where brand authority matters less than content quality and relevance. Build topical authority in specific sub-niches before competing on broad terms. Create ultra-specific, high-quality content that serves narrow user needs better than generalist content from larger competitors.

Consider: Wikipedia and Forbes have massive authority, but a specialized blog can still outrank them for very specific queries where the specialized site provides superior value.

How does competitor analysis help with AI search like ChatGPT and Perplexity?

Analyze how competitors structure content for direct answers and featured snippets, as this same formatting works well for AI search citations. Use question research to identify queries AI engines answer. Content ranking well in traditional search often gets cited in AI-generated responses.

Additionally, backlinks and authority—critical for traditional SEO—also influence which sources AI engines trust and cite. Strengthening your traditional SEO position improves AI search visibility. Learn more about answer engine optimization.

Can I use competitor analysis for local SEO?

Absolutely. Analyze local competitors' Google Business Profiles, local citations, location-specific pages, and locally-focused content. Review their review acquisition strategies, local backlink sources (chambers of commerce, local news, community organizations), and how they optimize for "near me" searches and local intent keywords.

Local SEO competitor analysis follows the same framework but focuses on local ranking factors and geo-targeted search results.

Conclusion

SEO competitor analysis isn't about copying what your rivals do—it's about learning from proven strategies, identifying opportunities they've missed, and creating something better.

The most successful SEO practitioners don't guess which keywords to target, what content to create, or where to build links. They analyze what already works in their market, then improve upon it systematically.

Key Takeaways:

Identify your true SEO competitors — They're determined by who ranks for your target keywords, not who sells similar products

Use the 4-step framework — Identify → Keywords → Content/Links → Action provides a systematic approach with any tool

Prioritize actionable insights — Collect enough data to make informed decisions, then execute rather than endlessly analyzing

Focus on quick wins first — Target low-difficulty keywords, fix technical issues, and optimize existing content while planning longer-term strategies

Tools accelerate but don't replace strategy — Frase, Semrush, and Ahrefs provide data faster, but strategic thinking drives results

The Frase Advantage

While traditional SEO tools excel at showing keyword volume and backlink counts, Frase's question research capabilities reveal opportunities competitors haven't discovered. By identifying unanswered questions in your niche, you can create content that:

• Serves user intent more precisely
• Captures featured snippets and PAA placements
• Gets cited by AI search engines (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews)
• Ranks faster by targeting less competitive question-based queries

Question-based optimization represents the future of search—voice queries, AI answers, and featured snippets all prioritize content that directly answers specific questions.

Your Next Steps

1. Identify your top 3-5 SEO competitors today — Use manual SERP analysis or tools to find who consistently outranks you
2. Run a keyword gap analysis — Use Frase's free trial to discover keywords competitors rank for that you're missing
3. Create your action plan — Use the prioritization framework to focus on high-impact opportunities
4. Implement quick wins — Target low-hanging fruit in the next 30 days to build momentum
5. Schedule quarterly reviews — Set calendar reminders to reassess your competitive landscape every 90 days

Final Thought

The most valuable competitor insights aren't what your rivals are doing—they're what they're NOT doing. Content gaps, unanswered questions, broken backlink opportunities, and technical weaknesses represent your clearest path to outranking established competitors.

Start with the framework in this guide. Analyze systematically. Act decisively. Measure results. Iterate based on what works.

Your competitors have shown you the path to rankings and traffic. Now it's your turn to improve upon it.

---

Ready to outrank your competition? Frase's SEO and content optimization tools make competitor analysis faster and more actionable. Discover keyword opportunities, analyze top-ranking content, and create optimized briefs that help you beat the competition.

Start Free Trial | Compare Frase vs Surfer SEO